WRITER: SIMON
GIANNAKIS
Disclaimer &
Disclosure: Please review
our policy as outlined on our website www.thatstockguy.NET
.
Intended
Audience
Individuals looking for different saving options with the goal of
sheltering tax on earned investment income.
Summary
Points to Take Away
(1) Benefits of a TFSA: (a) Income Splitting Opportunities
(b) Tax Free Income and Withdrawals (c) Flexibility of Investment Options (d)
Indefinite Carry-Forward of Contribution Room (e) No Income Requirement for
Eligibility.
(2) TFSAs are different than Registered Retirement Savings
Plan (RRSPs) in the following ways: (a) Contribution room for RRSPs is a
function of the individual's earned income; as compared to TFSAs which are the
same amongst all Canadians (b) Withdrawals from an RRSP are fully taxable,
unlike those from a TFSA which aren't. (c) Contributions to an RRSP are
deductable from taxable income in the year of the contribution, while for TFSA
contributions are not tax deductable.
What
is a Tax Free Savings Account (TFSA)?
Overview
A Tax
Free Savings Account (TFSA) is a savings tool new to Canadians starting 2009.
All investment income generated in the account is not subjected to tax. The
contribution limit for 2009 is $5,000, which can be carried forward
indefinitely.
Eligibility
Any
Canadian resident age 18 or older with a Social Insurance Number can open a
TFSA.
Why
Take Advantage of a TFSA?
Income Splitting
Opportunities
TFSA
allows for income splitting opportunities between higher and lower income
spouses given that attribution rules do not apply for income earned within the
account. When considering the eligibility rules stated earlier (that the
contribution room is not based on earned income) in theory a stay at home spouse
could have the income earner of the family contribute toward both their TFSA and
towards that of the stay at home spouse, with the end result being a lower
family tax bill. This is an effective tax splitting strategy as long as each
spouse has a different marginal tax rate (which is the case for most families)
as it involves taking more taxable investment income out of the higher income
spouse's hands.
Tax Free Income and
Withdrawals
Earnings from investments in a TFSA, whether it is interest, dividends or
capital gains are never subject
to Canadian tax. Taxes aren't paid even upon withdraw from the account. This is
unlike RRSP's, which only allows for the deferral of tax as the individual is
ultimately taxed upon withdrawal. The TFSA doesn't defer tax on investment
income; it eliminates it, which is one advantage it has over
RRSPs.
Flexibility of Investment
Options
Qualified investments for a TFSA include most financial products such as:
Saving Accounts, GICs, Mutual Funds, Stocks, and Bonds or a mix of all or some
of these various investment vehicles. Allowing for all these options makes a
TFSA appropriate for almost everyone as these options cover off the majority of
investment products that average individual sinks their savings into. In
addition there is no foreign content restriction on the selection of investments
such as pre 2005 RRSPs had.
Indefinite Carry forward
of Contribution Room
TFSA
contribution room is carry forwarded indefinitely; thus, individuals can
contribute when cash becomes available. The available contribution room will be
tracked by CRA and outlined on an individual's notice of assessment received
after the filing of their personal tax return. Withdrawals from their TFSA are
also added to the available unused contribution room starting the following
year.
No Income Requirement for
Eligibility
You don't
need to have earned income to contribute to a TFSA. This is extremely beneficial
for retirees and stay at home spouses. As well, there is no claw back on the
TFSA contribution room for higher income individuals, anyone who meets
eligibility requirements is entitled to the same contribution room (which for 2009 is
$5k, indexed to inflation - increases in $500 increments) regardless if your earned
income is $0 or $150k.
How it Compares to RRSPs
RRSP
(Retirement Savings Plan) TFSA (Tax
Free Savings Account) Contribution Room 18% of previous
year's earned income (less any pension adjustment), up to the maximum
annual RRSP contribution limit for the year set by the CRA (2008's limit
is $20,000) $5,000 for 2009,
which is indexed to inflation from that point
forward. Eligibility Individuals with
earned income (see above) Any Canadian
resident 18 years of age or older. Regardless of whether he or she is an
income earner or not. Withdrawals - Tax
Impact All withdrawals
are added to an individual's taxable income and subject to tax. Depending
on the level of the withdrawal - a withholding tax (i.e. taxed in advance, so
the individual receives the net upon withdrawal) is
applied. No taxable income
generated upon withdrawal. Investment
Income - Tax Impact Tax is deferred -
as mentioned above, withdrawals from an RRSP plan is added to an
individual's taxable income. Tax isn't
deferred - it is eliminated as withdrawals are not taxable (see
above). Contributions - Tax
Impact Contributions made
during the year within the maximum contribution room are deductable from
taxable income in the year of the
contribution. Contributions
aren't deductable from taxable income; merely the investment income earned
is sheltered from
taxes.
Other
Points
If you make a
TFSA contribution beyond the maximum allowable amount it is considered
an over-contribution. The CRA will assess a penalty of 1% per month on your
excess contribution. Similar rules apply for an RRSP as well, though there is a $2K
permitted over-contribution level before penalties apply.
Given that investment
income and capital gains within a TFSA are not taxed, any capital losses
generated in the account can't be used against taxable gains outside the
account.
Where to go from
here?
Remember the longer an individual's
investments are in a TFSA, the faster they'll grow as the tax free income will
compound at a higher rate. An RRSP is
primarily intended for retirement. The TFSA is like
an RRSP for everything else people save for (i.e. savings for short term
purchases, supplemental long term income, tax shelter against investment income
earned outside of an RRSP, etc). Put your highest taxable investments in your
TFSA (i.e. if own shares of BCE and GICs outside of a TFSA, ensure you place the
GIC's into the account first since it produces interest income which is 100%
taxable as appose to investment gains from BCE, which would be made up of
dividends and capital gains, which are both taxed at a lower level than interest
income).
Would love to hear your feedback, contact thatstockguy.NET@gmail.com.
Thanks,
Simon
Simon Giannakis is the founder and creator of www.thatstockguy.NET . He is a Senior Accountant within the Assurance and Advisory group at an international public accounting firm in Toronto, Ontario. Simon is a Chartered Accountant and currently pursuing his CFA designation. Simon can be contacted through thatstockguy.net@gmail.com .