Disclaimer & Disclosure: Please review our policy as outlined on our website www.thatstockguy.NET . As well note, the
writer of the article and his direct family members do not currently hold a financial position in TIH.Intended Audience
Personal investors looking at
opportunities that pose both a mix of investment income through dividends and
capitalgains through share appreciation.
As well, investors following the construction industry.
Summary Points to Take
Away
(1) Strong Points: (a) Steady
Dividend Income (b) Stable Operating Performance (c) No Financing Issues
(d)Growth Opportunities (e) Stock
buyback program (f) Positive Free Cash Flow Production.
(2) Risks: (a) Stock Heavily Followed by Analysts (b) Revenue Increasing at Decreasing Rate (c) CustomerIssues (d) Forward P/E is Not Significantly Undervalued.
Analysis
Toromont Industries Limited is a Canadian
based company listed on the TSX under ticker symbol TIH. The
Companyserves its customers through two
business groups: (1) The Equipment Group (EG) (2) The Compression Group
(CG).The EG sells, rents and services a
range of construction equipment and industrial engines. The EG is comprised
of Toromont CAT and Battlefield The
CAT Rental Store. The activities of the EG include sales and product
supportactivities for Caterpillar engines
used in a range of applications, including on highway trucks, industrial,
commercial,marine and power generation
applications. The CG is engaged in the design, engineering, fabrication and
installationof compression systems for natural
gas, fuel gas and carbon dioxide, as well as process systems, and industrial
andrecreational refrigeration systems.
During the year ended December 31, 2007, the EG represented 58% and the
CGrepresented 42% of the total
revenues. As of Q3 2008, this business composition has shifted resulting in both
groupsbeing relatively more equal as the
CG has seen strong gains from the natural gas compression customers.
Positive Factors
Steady Dividend Income
Current dividend yield based on
last quoted market price of $24 is 2.3% assuming an annual dividend of $0.56
pershare (which is 2008 payout).
Provides a cushion for investors in addition to the expectation of capital
appreciation.TIH has raised the annual dividend
for 19 consecutive years; thus, demonstrating management's ability and desire
toreward shareholders in good times
and in bad as both were experienced during that time frame. A significant
numberof corporations pay dividends
during boom periods but scale back during recessionary periods. TIH continues to
notonly pay dividends, but increases
them year after year, which provides a strong assurance of constant
dividendincome now and into the
future.
Stable Operating Performance
Both gross profit and operating income as a % of revenue have remained stable during the past 4 quarters as well asduring fiscal years 2004 to 2007 with gross profit at around 20 to 23% and operating income at 9 to 10%. Thiscoincides with TIH's ability to continue dividend payments to shareholders with annual increases. The stability ofthese fundamental performance metrics will enable TIH the ability to continue paying dividends to investors. TIH is amajor player within their market; thus, have power over customers to retain margins even in tough economic times;thus, margin and operation income are expected to continue.
No Financing Issues
TIH has $203M left in available
credit facilities that has been not drawned down on with the majority of the
facilityexpiring in 2011; thus, providing
adequate time frame for renewal. To put the available credit in perspective, TIH
hasenough cash available to continue
dividend payouts for 22 quarters (little over 5 years), even with no cash
flowcontributions from
operations.
Total debt only makes up 11% of total assets as of Q3 2008, which has fallen quarter after quarter since fiscal year2005 (high point of 21% of total assets). Excess cash is being used wisely by TIH as evidenced by the two biggestuses of free cash flow: (1) rewarding shareholders through dividend income (2) reduction of outstanding debt. Totalcash on hand as of Q3 2008 was $239M, as compared to long term debt of $175M; thus, cash exceeds debt by 1.4:1.Current ratio and quick ratio as of Q3 are 1.91 and 0.98, which are close to the 2:1 and 1:1 industry rules of thumb.Working capital accounts can reveal valuation issues if they continue to build up, but for TIH accounts receivable andinventory, as a % of assets have remained relatively flat year over year since 2005.
Growth Opportunities
Two significant growth
opportunities have been outlined during TIH's August 2008 investor presentation
(specifically within the equipment rental side
of the business, which represents roughly 52% of total operations):
(1) Mining Sector: Majority of mining sector business comes from Canada and it currently makes up a minor %of total equipment rental revenue. Given that mining is a very significant industry in Canada where manyprojects are underway that require equipment rental services, TIH expects to see higher demand from thisarea. Currently there are 70 mines in operation within TIH's territory as well as over 60 projects in somestage of development, which upon completion will almost double mines in operation; thus, leading to higherexpectations of demand for TIH equipment rental products.
(2) Infrastructure Industry: Government bodies in both the US and Canada have outlined aggressiveinfrastructure budgets to be carried out over the next few years, which will mean significant levels ofinfrastructure construction that will require equipment rentals and technical support. Canada's currentinfrastructure budget commits $33 billion to projects through to 2014. While in the US, the current estimatesare $700 billion (but will be known with more certainty as Obama takes his presidency).
Stock Buy Backs
TIH's board has approved buybacks
up to 4.6 million shares as of August 31, 2008 expiring in 12 months.
Thepotential buyback is a significant
part of the current outstanding float and total potential diluted shares, 10%
and 8%respectively. If this is acted
upon, it'll benefit shareholders through capital appreciation and is further
evidence thatmanagement is focused on rewarding
the shareholders, not wasting excess cash on poor acquisitions, etc.
Investorsshould follow this situation
closely as though this is good for shareholders in theory, management has yet to
makeany stock buy backs based on the
current approved buyback limit, nor did they buy back any shares during the last
4quarters. This isn't a benefit to
investors till management exercises their right to purchase up to 4.6 million
shares.During the past 4 quarters, the
trend has been the opposite, where ownership has become more diluted due
toexercising of employee options no
buy back to decrease the total outstanding shares. Total diluted shares have
gonefrom 64.7 million shares to 65.13
during the last 4 quarters, and have been further diluted in comparison to
2005'slevel of 63.08 million.
Positive FCF
Free cash flow is the most relevant
cash flow performance metric to monitor for TIH because capital expenditures
area required to maintain and grow
revenue levels. Due to that factor, FCF provides the more realistic measure of
howmuch cash is available for use
(i.e. to pay down debt, buy back shares or provide dividend income to
shareholders).During the last 4 quarters, the
accumulated FCF produced has been approximately 10% of the current share price
of$24; thus, based on this
understanding, TIH produced enough cash to pay out a theoretical dividend yield
of 10%based on a market price of
$24.
During the last 4 quarters, TIH produced $157M of free cash flow, which is approximately equal to 90% of presentlong term debt as of Q3 2008 ($175M); thus, if TIH continues their pace, long term debt can be paid off within twoyears even under the assumption that current dividend level continues.
Risks
Heavily Followed Stock
Approximately nine analysts follow
TIH; thus, the stock is heavily followed implying that the stock price has a
higherprobability of being closer to its
intrinsic value, given the theory that the more investors following a stock the
lesslikely the stock price shall divert from
its real value. Peter Lynch, famed author of "One up on Wall street" and
"Beating the street" claimed that
identifying stocks with little analyst coverage was key to obtaining abnormal
stockreturns. TIH has a market
capitalization of $1.6 billion; therefore difficult for the value of the company
to growsignificantly (i.e. double or
triple) as compared to smaller companies, for example growing from $100M market
cap to$1 billion, as compared to going
from $1 billion to $100 billion for larger corporations.
Revenue Increasing at Decreasing
Rate
Revenue has risen over the past few
years, but at a decreasing rate showing signs the business is entering
thematuring phase where growth is in
line with movements in GDP; thus, significant capital appreciation from growth
isnot as likely. Revenue growth has
gone from 12% in 2005, to 10% in 2006 and then dropping in 2007 as well as
thelast 4 quarters to 8%. TIH has
grown to the point that sustaining a rising sales growth rate is likely not
realistic as themarket capitalization of the
company has already reached $1.6 billion.
Customer Issues
As discussed in TIH's Q3 MD&A,
many of TIH's customers are reliant upon access to credit and equity
capitalmarkets to finance the projects for
which TIH's products are used for. An inability to finance some of these
projectswould adversely impact TIH's
business prospects. Given the current state of the credit market, cost of
raising moneyhas increased significantly in the
latter half of 2008 and is expected to continue in 2009, which would lead to
lowerdemand and drops in backlogs as
changes in present financing options could lead to the cancellation of
previouslyapproved capital projects. Continue
to monitor the credit situation as it'll impact revenue estimations for
TIH.
Forward P/E
Based on the last 4 quarters of
earnings, P/E is roughly 12 times earnings (based on market price of $24), which
ischeaper than the stocks historical
high, but is not relative to other companies within the market that are selling
for halfthe P/E ratio. Trailing P/E is
likely a reflection of the future P/E as growth as value gained from growth
opportunitieswill be offset by fewer projects
from current customer base. Keep an eye on the stock price to see if the stock
goeson sale, which could make it a good
buy at that point as the fundamentals of the company are strong.
Where to go from here?
Overall at the current price level
of $24, suggested action is to be neutral on the stock (take no action
regardless ofown or not), while following it
closely to take advantage of purchases at the lower end of its 52 week low. In
this case,TIH has strong fundamentals, but
the stock price seems to reflect that. TIH is a publicly traded company on the
TSX.
Would love to hear your
feedback, contact thatstockguy.NET@gmail.com.
Thanks,
Simon
Simon
Giannakis is the founder and creator of www.thatstockguy.NET . He is a Senior Accountant within
the Assurance and Advisory group at an international
public accounting firm in Toronto, Ontario. Simon is a Chartered
Accountant and currently pursuing his CFA designation. Simon can be contacted through
thatstockguy.net@gmail.com
.